An update: Apparently one instructor is now the focus of the investigation as it appears he provided the material to the cadets.
EMS Cheating Probe Focuses On Instructor
The person familiar with the probe said an investigator proclaimed, “Now that we know one instructor is responsible for this incident, my problem is to determine how deep it goes.”
City fire chief suspends EMS training after cheating revealed
Baltimore fire officials suspended emergency medical training and locked down an instructional facility Monday after revelations that some student firefighters had cheated on a state licensing exam, officials said.
“This is a serious mistake that tarnishes the reputation of the hundreds of professional and dedicated men and women who work so hard for us,” Fire Chief James S. Clack said in a statement.
Mistake? I wouldn’t quite call it a mistake. Lapse of judgment, maybe, but not a mistake. This was something done purposefully to achieve a certification not earned, but stolen.
The students had obtained details about the mock victim and the scenario, but it is unclear how many students were involve
Because we know that in real life, every medical scenario is going to be provided to you in advance.
Twenty students who took the test on June 14 will be required to repeat it, Clack said. The class is expected to graduate in August, and there is no indication that the incident would delay the class’ graduation, a Fire Department spokesman said.
Think about the message this is sending. “We take this very seriously {wink}, but we’ll let you retest {nod}, and if you pass you get to be real life firefighters. {guffaw}. That tells the public exactly how serious you are about this theft of tax dollars.
Way back in 2007, there was another cheating investigation but,
Clack, who became chief after the cheating came to light, ultimately decided to accept the scores of the students who had been accused of cheating.
Here’s my solution. If the investigation reveals that any of the cadets cheated on the exam, fire them. Baltimore can probably find twenty people who won’t cheat. The Mayor should ask for the resignation of the Fire Chief. He’s shown twice that he does not take allegations of cheating seriously, therefore he has no credibility. The entire fire department, especially the EMS division is now compromised in the eyes of the public, nothing short of a new chief will fix that.
Former Chief William J. Goodwin Jr., who retired several months after Wilson’s death, said that he was required to hire only city residents during his tenure — and found that city high school graduates struggled with the written exams.
“We had to do some remedial science and English classes, because that’s what the test is basically,” he said.
That tells us all we need to know about the Baltimore Public Schools and the wisdom of residency requirements for hiring.
Here is another story on the investigation,
Fire Academy Program Suspended Amid Cheating Probe
“When something like this happens, it reflects on the whole agency, reflects on me,” Baltimore City Fire Department Chief James Clacksaid. “It reflects on the fire department and the city. Unfortunately, somebody decided to do something they shouldn’t have, and we are all going to pay the price for that.”
Damn right, Chief. All the more reason for you to go.
Another victory for fire based EMS. What the city does with the cadets, any instructors involved in this mess, and the chief will say a lot about how serious they are about EMS.
Cheating is wrong, but I do not see this as an indictment of only fire based EMS. There are plenty of liars and cheats everywhere, and I think that this is more an indictment of today’s society. No one wants to work for what they get, they all want the easy cheat codes for their video games and their lives.
There is no cheat code for life.
While you are correct that there is cheating everywhere, it seems that there is a culture of cheating when it comes to EMS within the fire service. Why is it that we never hear of someone cheating on a fire fighting examination? I’m sure that in the academy fire fighters have to take written and practical tests. Yet every cheating scandal in the fire service seems to involve EMS training.
I have a lot of respect for you and AD both, but your ongoing dislike for firemedics is pretty obvious. Maybe because you don’t like firefighters, you aren’t looking:
Orlando: http://www.wftv.com/news/26497305/detail.html
Boston: http://www.masscops.com/f11/cheating-fire-exam-alleged-44563/
Baltimore: http://www.vnnforum.com/showthread.php?t=52243
San Francisco: http://blogs.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2011/05/black_firefighters_art_kenney.php
Colorado: http://www.kdvr.com/news/kdvr-official-firefighters-cheated-on-state-certification-test-20110510,0,2699278.story
Houston: http://www.myfoxhouston.com/dpp/news/local/110118-possible-cheating-on-houston-firefighters-promotions-exams
Wisconsin: http://www.mansfieldnewsjournal.com/article/20110720/NEWS01/107200310/Madison-firefighters-accused-cheating-2009-exam
Try to be a little more objective. It isn’t just firefighters who cheat on EMS classes. I have had nurses and non-fire paramedics sit in my ACLS classes and complain because I made them do the scenarios. One nurse actually told me that she should have done what her friends did: there was a guy who was selling ACLS cards to nurses for $100.
I got the name of the guy and turned him in. He is out of business now.
My dislike for fire based EMS is based on years of experience. The fire service, through their representatives in the IAFF and IAFC has been disingenuous to say the least. First the IAFF, as a union, rants and raves about non union fire fighters (volunteers) taking food out of fire fighters kid’s mouths. Then, they go around and take over non fire based union EMS systems and try to displace the existing work force so they can be replaced with fire fighters. Not to mention all the side jobs that fire fighters have as carpenters, plumbers, electricians, where they aren’t members of those unions. Not mention their blatant lies about it being about “patient care” when at the IAFF convention they talk about nothing but taking over EMS to preserve their jobs.
The IAFF, like most unions, is about collecting dues. I used to be a volunteer, and I am now a non-union employee in a union shop. I quit the union when I saw how much BS it was. That has nothing to do with the care I deliver. I know quite a few non-fire paramedics that royally suck balls, just like I know firemedics who suck. I still say that it is about your personal work ethic, not who signs your paycheck.
Read my post:
http://street-pharmacy.blogspot.com/2011/07/work-ethic-100-and-dilbert-philosophy.html
and see how I feel about work ethic.
I gotta wonder what the point is of you trying to defend fire-medics and then posting a half-dozen stories about cheating firefighters- many if not most of whom, I’m sure, are fire-medics. You aren’t really helping your case.
My point is that there are a lot of idiots in the fire service, but I don’t think that this fact points to a lack of appreciation for EMS, I think it points to a general lack of work ethic in many fire departments, especially in large cities. It is my belief that the large city departments have become jobs programs for people with no work ethic or desire to excel.
I think that this is different from saying that fire medics are somehow inferior to medics elsewhere. I also think that this is an indictment of those departments, and not on the fire service as a whole.
I have never understood this whole penis envy thing that non-fire service medics seem to have with firemedics. Is it jealousy? After all, firemedics:
– Make more money, receive better benefits
– Are based in a station, while non-fire medics sit in their truck on the corner
– have more job security
– better working conditions
I know, I have done both.
Yeah, I know they’re station-based. Which, where my parents live, will often leads to 15-minute response times, or longer, because god forfreakinbid the hero firefighters on the far end of town be forced to leave their station when the other ambulance stationed closer to the call are already committed. In any decent non-fire system, the remaining truck would have been re-deployed to a more central location. But that area doesn’t have La-Z-Boys.
Even transferring to one of their other stations would be an improvement, but nope- can’t make them move. That’d get a grievance filed before the shift is over.
(And you do know that there are delivery models other than fire and private, right? (Boston EMS is station-based, for example, and many other municipal-run systems do the same. Hell, there are many privates in Massachusetts that *gasp* share quarters with the firefighters!)
I turned down a FF/paramedic job in my home town because the pay was 40% less than what I was making. The only real advantage was the schedule, but most of the time off would have been eaten up by the second job I’d need to make that up. Other than that benefits were pretty much the same and since I’ve been with the same outfit for 30+ years, I’m not worried about job security. The only corner sit on is the one where the pretty girls come out of the night clubs after the bars close. I consider that a fringe benefit.
and to add: one reason why there is more cheating seen in EMS is that the instructors and schools are the ones proctoring the exams in many cases, and with firefighting certifications, it is a government administered test.
BS. In the Baltimore case, it was a MIEMS employee who discovered the cheating by a city fire fighter.
I’m not saying that people are less likely to cheat at a government proctored test, I am saying that they are less likely to get caught, and when they do, it is less likely to be published.
[…] there was another training scandal in Baltimore, Maryland. TOTWTYTR shared his thoughts here and Hybrid Medic shared his thoughts here. I share the same thoughts and feelings as both TOTWTYTR […]