This is actually fairly serious stuff, since it involves preventing a potential injury to human sex organs.
A Release Valve for Cyclists’ Unrelenting Pressure
It’s the area of soft tissue called the perineum, and it’s not just a male problem — female cyclists have also reported soreness and numbness in this genital region. But neither sex seems interested in these saddles, and I’m as baffled as Mr. Brown is by their apathy.
I do a fair amount of bike riding too, between 10-15 miles per day, depending on a number of variables. I have more than one bike, but the one I ride the most has a noseless saddle on it. When I first started riding, about seven years ago I noticed the symptoms that were described. It was very uncomfortable and cut into my enthusiasm for riding. I did some research on noseless bike saddles and came across the Moonsaddle. While it looks funny and takes a bit of getting used to, it works well and now I feel strange trying to ride without it. I haven’t put one on my secondary bike (a mountain bike) yet, but I have tilted the traditional style saddle down at an angle to reduce pressure on my perineum and make riding a bit more comfortable. Of course mountain bike saddles are built a bit differently than road saddles, especially in terms of padding.
“There’s as much penis inside the body as outside,” Dr. Schrader told me. “When you sit on a regular bike saddle, you’re sitting on your penis.”
Well there’s a medical fun fact you won’t find on the NREMT exam. But, it’s an important point.
It’s an important enough an issue that the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) has issued a recommendation that police officers and other people who spend a long part of their work day on bicycles switch to noseless saddles.
But, of course there are some people, in this case it seems a majority, of people who don’t agree,
“I suppose there’s a small niche of people for whom a noseless saddle might be a solution,” Mr. Flax said. “But a saddle without a nose has real problems in terms of function. A cyclist can make turns using the weight in the hips against the nose. I just don’t think a noseless saddle is safe in a race.”
Well, Mr. Flax here are couple of points for you to ponder. First, this is based on science, not tradition. Also, most bike riders are NOT racers. In fact, I’d say that most people who ride bikes ride for fun and exercise, with a smattering riding to save the environment or even gas money. I don’t know if I’m atypical as a bike rider, but I have no pretensions of being Lance Armstrong and winning the Tour de France. I ride because it increases my aerobic capacity and helps me decrease my weight. I think there are a lot more riders like me than elite racers out there. If more of them knew about the variety of noseless saddles available, I suspect more of them would use them.
The BiSaddle, which is mentioned in the article seems a bit spendy to me, but there are other options. The Times article does not mention the Moonsaddle, but does mention several other brands of saddle sans nose.
Let’s hear some more wisdom from Mr. Flax,
“Serious bike riders would be totally embarrassed to show up at a race in a noseless saddle,” Mr. Flax said.
Well, they’ll be seriously embarrassed if one day Mr. Happy doesn’t stand at attention when their significant other is expecting something after the race. If you get my drift.
Well, there’s a certain logic to that retail strategy, at least for the short term. But if you’re in it for the long term, if you’d like your customers to keep cycling — and creating new customers — then it pays to protect the perineum.
The perineum and the delicate structures that run through it. It would seem to make business sense to inform customers and potential customers about a potentially serious problem and some ways to avoid it.
Don’t get me wrong, I do enjoy watching a great bike race (including the tour). I also hope that the doping that has been prevalent in that sport (and many others) is being curtailed.
That said, do you think Floyd Landis’ willy can stand up after all the ‘roids? Probably hasn’t been an issue for the pro group…that stuff stopped working long before perineal pressure became problematic.
I’m reasonably happy with my current saddle, but I’ll be looking carefully at noseless or one of the other higher-quality male saddles…just to be safe. Thanks for the reminder of these!
I’m not particularly interested in Floyd Landis’ wedding tackle, he can, uh, handle that on his own. I AM worried about my comfort on rides and the saddle from the beginning was the biggest problem. It is true that any noseless saddle can put more pressure on the wrists and hands than a traditional one. Still that’s partially a matter of adjusting your riding style. At least I’ve found it so. I was looking at a Schwinn noseless seat on line today for my mountain/hybrid bike. At under $20.00 plus shipping, if I don’t like it for use on my bike, I can try it on my stationary bike. Interestingly, I still get some discomfort when I ride that. Interesting to me, that is.
TOTW,
I only mentioned Floyd because of the claims that racers would take issue with a noseless saddle. Then again, if they ain’t working already, I guess it doesn’t matter to them.
“There’s as much penis inside the body as outside,” Dr. Schrader told me. “When you sit on a regular bike saddle, you’re sitting on your penis.”
So you’re saying I can start measuring from my anus now?
Cool!
That will stretch the old micrometer out, won’t it?
First I have ever heard about a noseless bike seat. If it could help me ride longer and harder it is certainly worth a look.
As I said, I like the Moonsaddle. Compared to some of the seats mentioned in this NYT article, it’s pretty reasonable. It does take some getting used to, in fact they used to tell customers to try it for 60 days and if they weren’t happy they could return it.
I’m definitely getting the Schwinn for my stationary bike, it’s cheap and has to be more comfortable than what’s on there now.
Great article. This is a problem for female cyclist too. The Moonsaddle takes some getting used to. Definitely give it a try and keep an open mind about it. Looks queer. Also a split seat works well too (don’t know about for men though).